行政复议与行政诉讼受案范围的衔接
On the Scope Consistency of the Administrative Reconsideration and Judicial Review
-
摘要: 根据我国现行立法, 行政复议与行政诉讼受案范围的不一致表现出有三大类案件 不能纳入人民法院的司法审查范围, 导致部分行政权不能得到有效的司法监督。 导致这种现象的 直接原因是立法技术上的缺陷, 更深层次的原因是中国长期的行政权的膨胀。 然而依法治国方略 意味着控权制度和权力制衡原则被遵守, 所以行政复议与行政诉讼的衔接就应当一方面保障行政 复议制度的中立性和公正性, 另一方面扩大司法审查的范围, 只有这样才能有效监督权力, 实现保 障公民权利的立法目的Abstract: The scope inconsistency of the administrative review and administrative litigation has led to that some of the executive power can not be effectively supervised by the judicial power This irrational phenomenon is manifested in the present laws and regulations in China, as that there are three categories of cases are not within the scope of judicial review The deficiency in the scope of the administrative litigation will lead to the unlimited expansion of executive power, because power without supervision will lead to the abuse of the power However, the establishment of rule of law as strat - egy of government and the system of power control mean that there should be a balance among the powers, and that jud-i cial power is bound to supervise the administrative power In order to effectively achieve the supervision of the judicial power over the administrative power, the scope consistency of the administrative review and legal review should be rea-l ized
下载: